Colton Underwood Doesn’t Belong in Conservative spaces

written by a member of the WCB

Colton Underwood, the former star of The Bachelor, has found himself at the center of controversy within conservative circles, but it’s crucial to clarify that this exclusion has little to do with his sexual identity. Instead, it stems from a broader dissonance between his public persona and the values traditionally upheld by conservative constituents.

Since coming out as gay in 2021, Underwood’s garnered significant media attention, positioning himself as a prominent advocate for LGBTQ+ rights. While many conservatives champion the importance of individual freedom and personal expression, Underwood’s approach often clashes with the foundational principles of the conservative movement. His narrative frequently emphasizes a departure from traditional values, which can alienate those who hold steadfast to the tenets of conservatism.

Moreover, Underwood’s actions and statements have sometimes appeared contradictory to the conservative ethos. For instance, his participation in high-profile media campaigns and reality television often prioritizes sensationalism over substantive discourse. This tendency can be perceived as undermining the serious discussions surrounding issues that matter to conservative audiences, such as family values, fiscal responsibility, and national security.

Additionally, Underwood's past behavior, including allegations of harassment and his tumultuous relationships, raises questions about his alignment with conservative ideals. Many conservatives advocate for accountability and integrity, and his public missteps have led to skepticism regarding his commitment to these principles. This skepticism’s compounded by the perception that he seeks to leverage his celebrity status for personal gain rather than contribute meaningfully to the conservative dialogue.

Colton Underwood’s exclusion from conservative spaces isn’t a reflection of his sexual identity but rather a consequence of his perceived divergence from the core values that define the movement. As conservatives navigate the complexities of modern identity politics, it’s essential to maintain a clear distinction between supporting individual rights and endorsing individuals whose actions and narratives may not align with conservative principles.